Instrumentation Questions Part One

Whether you are a student, an aspiring engineer, or an industry professional looking to upskill, one of the first questions that comes to mind is, "Which PLC brand should I start with?" This question is important and necessary because the choice of a PLC brand can impact your learning and training experience, career prospects, and the projects you undertake.

In this article, we will explore several popular PLC brands and help you decide which one is the best fit for your needs.

Understanding PLCs

A PLC is a digital computer used for automation of industrial electromechanical processes, such as control of machinery on factory assembly lines, amusement rides, or light fixtures. PLCs are designed for multiple input and output arrangements, extended temperature ranges, and resistance to electromagnetic interference. The fundamental characteristics of PLCs include:

• They can handle a variety of control problems.
• PLCs are built to hold out harsh industrial environments.
• They can be easily expanded to accommodate additional input/output devices.
• PLCs use various programming languages, including ladder logic, which resembles electrical relay logic.

Top PLC Brands to Consider

Let’s evaluate some of the most popular PLC brands available today. Each of these brands has its unique features, advantages, and learning resources, making them suitable for different users:

1. Allen-Bradley (Rockwell Automation)

Overview: Allen-Bradley is one of the most recognized names in automation technology. It is a product line of Rockwell Automation and offers a wide range of PLCs, including the CompactLogix and ControlLogix series.

Pros:
Allen-Bradley is widely used across various industries, from manufacturing to processing. This reputation provides solid career opportunities.
Extensive documentation, online forums, and user communities are available for learning and troubleshooting.
The RSLogix/Studio 5000 software suite is user-friendly and allows for seamless programming and simulation.

Cons: Allen-Bradley products are often more expensive compared to other brands.

Best For:
Those looking for a comprehensive, industry-standard experience with a clear career path in automation.

2. Siemens

Overview: Siemens is another leading player in the automation industry, particularly in Europe. Their S7 series of PLCs, including the S7-1200 and S7-1500, are highly popular.

Pros:

• Siemens PLCs come with innovative features like integrated Web servers and data logging.
• Siemens is globally recognized, providing ample opportunities for work in international settings.
• It supports different programming languages, including ladder logic and structured text.

Cons: Some users find Siemens software to be less intuitive than competitors.

Best For:
Individuals interested in cutting-edge technology and global career opportunities, particularly if they plan to work in Europe or industries like automotive and manufacturing.

3. Mitsubishi Electric

Overview: Mitsubishi Electric offers a wide range of PLCs, including the MELSEC series, which are known for their compact design and reliability.

Pros:

• Typical for applications where space is a constraint.
• Offers a balance between features and cost, making it suitable for various applications.
• The GX Works software simplifies programming and debugging operations.

Cons: Their primary market is in Asia, which may limit accessibility to support and community resources in other parts of the world.

Best For:
Those seeking an affordable PLC solution for smaller operations and individuals working in Asian markets.

4. Schneider Electric (Modicon)

Overview: Schneider Electric’s Modicon brand is well-known for its innovative automation solutions. The Modicon M221, M241, and M580 PLCs are popular options.

Pros:

• Schneider focuses on IoT integration and energy efficiency.
• Allows for greater flexibility in networking and integration with other systems.
• Comprehensive online resources and user communities.

Cons: While Schneider offers solid PLC options, their range is not as vast as competitors like Allen-Bradley.

Best For:
Professionals looking for flexible and energy-efficient PLC solutions, particularly in the energy and utilities sectors.

5. Omron

Overview: Omron provides a variety of automation solutions, including a robust line of PLCs such as the CJ2 and NX series.

Pros:

• Omron PLCs are known for their modular designs, making it easy to customize and expand systems.
• Particularly beneficial for industries that require precise motion control.
• Omron often offers reasonably priced training kits and resources.

Cons: Omron might not be as recognized as other brands in certain regions.

Best For:
Individuals focused on motion control applications or those seeking to learn without a significant financial investment.

Factors to be Considered When Choosing the Brand of PLC

While examining these brands, consider the following factors to make an informed decision:

1. Industry Relevance: If you have a specific industry in mind, focus on brands that are prevalent in that field. For instance, if you aim to work in automotive manufacturing, Allen-Bradley or Siemens might offer advantages since they're widely used in that sector.
2. Learning Resources: Consider the availability of training materials, community forums, and professional support. The more accessible resources you find, the easier it will be to enhance your skills.
3. Budget: PLC systems can vary significantly in price. Assess your budget not only for the initial purchase but also for training materials and software.
4. Software: Look into the software provided by the brand for programming and debugging. User-friendly software can ease the learning curve, especially for beginners.
5. Scalability: If you anticipate growing your skills or the size of your projects, choose a PLC brand that offers modular options for expansion.

Conclusion: Choosing the right PLC brand can seem daunting at first, but understanding your needs and examining the strengths and weaknesses of each brand can guide you in the right direction. 

For those starting, Allen-Bradley and Siemens are excellent choices due to their widespread industry acceptance and robust support systems. On the other hand, brands like Mitsubishi and Omron can offer cost-effective solutions if you’re looking for budget-friendly options or concentrated on specific applications. 

Ultimately, the right PLC brand for you will depend on your individual needs, career goals, and the industries you wish to engage with.

Edit This Article